28mm Pros
- If I ever play at conventions or tournaments, this will be the standard size.
- Larger figures will be a nice change from 15mm.
- Larger scale is visually appealing.
1/72 (20mm) Pros
- Significantly less expensive than 28mm.
- Figures have less of a heroic figure.
- Will look better, visually, on my smaller table here in Korea.
- May be able to use for Blitzkrieg Commander or other WW II rulesets, too.
In an earlier post, I laid out the cost differences for various 28mm armies. A 1000 point German Wehrmacht veteran force consisting of three squads, two support units, a Hanomag halftrack, and a Panzer IV would run $82. Downgrading the infantry to regular training would allow be to throw in a second Hanomag, costing $104, and keeping the force around 1000 points.
Going with the Plastic Soldier Company's 1/72 figures, I could purchase one infantry box, one heavy weapons box, three Hanomags, and three Panzer IVs for $70. This set would allow me to easily field the same 1000 point force. In fact, I could field two full platoons with three halftracks and two tanks, as listed below, with figures remaining.
Wehrmacht German Force (Regular Rating)
|
||||
1st Platoon (Motorized)
|
|
2nd Platoon
|
||
|
1st Lt
|
|
|
1st Lt
|
|
Medic
|
|
|
Medic
|
|
Forward Observer
|
|
|
Forward Observer
|
Three Infantry Squads
|
|
Three Infantry Squads
|
||
each with
|
NCO w/SMG
|
|
each with
|
NCO w/SMG
|
|
Soldier with SMG
|
|
|
4 Riflemen
|
|
3 Riflemen
|
|
|
LMG Team
|
|
2 Panzer Faust
|
|
|
|
|
LMG Team
|
|
|
|
Weapons Squad
|
|
Weapons Squad
|
||
|
MMG Team
|
|
|
MMG Team
|
|
120mm Mortar
|
|
|
80mm Mortar
|
|
Panzerschreck
|
|
|
Panzerschreck
|
Transport
|
|
|
Transport
|
|
|
3 Hanomag
|
|
|
None
|
Armor
|
|
|
Armor
|
|
|
Panzer IV
|
|
|
Panzer IV
|
Total Points Value
|
1964
|
Armor Platoon Comparisons
Warlord Games recently provided a new rule for Bolt Action on their website, allowing you to fight with Armoured Platoons. The basic platoon is three tanks. For any infantry or weapons support, you must provide transports for all elements. The rule supplement can be found at the following link:
http://www.warlordgames.com/32598/bolt-action-armoured-platoon-selectors/
Let's compare a 28mm and 1/72 platoon, assuming I purchased the basic infantry platoon in 28mm (described in earlier post) and added more vehicles and elements.
Let's compare a 28mm and 1/72 platoon, assuming I purchased the basic infantry platoon in 28mm (described in earlier post) and added more vehicles and elements.
Panzer Platoon
|
Points
|
|
Armoured Platoon
|
|
|
Command Tank
|
Panzer IV
|
260
|
|
Panzer IV
|
235
|
|
Panzer IV
|
235
|
One Infantry Squad
|
106
|
|
|
NCO w/SMG
|
|
|
Soldier with SMG
|
|
|
3 Riflemen
|
|
|
2 Panzer Faust
|
|
|
LMG Team
|
|
Weapons Squad
|
195
|
|
|
MMG Team
|
|
|
120mm Mortar
|
|
|
Panzerschreck
|
|
Transport
|
|
|
|
2 Hanomag
|
168
|
Total Points Value
|
1199
|
|
1/72 Total Cost
|
$70
|
|
28mm Total Cost
|
$212
|
I have some more thinking to do. I'm almost finished with my DBA Later Persian army basing, and I am tackling a terrain project afterward. I'll probably purchase my first batch of WW II figures in the summer, starting with samples in both scales.
No comments:
Post a Comment